Sezione Locale della Società Psicoanalitica Italiana
KnotGarden 2026/2 – Sulla verità
di Dana Amir
(Tel Aviv). Membro Ordinario con Funzioni di Training della Società Psicoanalitica Israeliana. Full professor at Haifa University. IPA’s Hayman Prize 2017 e 2025. The International Sigourney Award 2025
*Per citare questo articolo:
Amir D. (2026). On the Violation and the Restoration of Truth. Rivista KnotGarden 2026/2, Centro Veneto di Psicoanalisi, pp. 242-257.
Per una lettura più agile e per ulteriori riferimenti di pagina si consiglia di scaricare la Rivista in formato PDF.
Nota della Curatrice:
This paper is a chapter in a forthcoming book titled “Grief Has No End,” issued by Routledge.
Il presente scritto è il capitolo del libro “Greif has no End” (Routledge) che Dana Amir ha gentilmente concesso alla nostra Rivista, prima ancora della sua pubblicazione finale. Per l’intensità e la precisione del linguaggio usato dalla collega, la curatrice ha preferito lasciare il testo in inglese. Il capitolo contiene una lettura psicoanalitica di drammatici fatti di attualità internazionale ed esprime opinioni riguardanti società e politica. Non è, invece, da considerarsi come rappresentativo delle opinioni di tutti i membri del CVP. Esso, infatti, espone la riflessione della dottoressa Amir che è psicoanalista israeliana, nota per il suo attivo impegno sociale. La ringraziamo per questa generosa condivisione.
This paper proposes a conceptual framework for understanding processes of violation and restoration of truth through the dynamic relationship between the forces of Guardianship from Above and Guardianship from Below, their distortion in traumatic zones, and their restoration through therapeutic processes. Extending these ideas to both the social and the clinical domains, the chapter argues that therapeutic and civic interventions alike are fundamentally concerned with restoring the conditions for thinking. Their task is to transform false forms of solidarity into authentic ones, to recover causality where it has been replaced by ideological rationalization, and to reclaim the temporal and psychic space necessary for thought.
One morning, about a week and a half after the October 7 attack, I was standing in line at a neighborhood bakery. On the face of it, an ordinary, inconsequential moment. The song Imagine was playing in the background. Suddenly, I felt tears welling up inside me, tears that had not come during any of the days preceding that morning. It was precisely in a moment emptied of conscious intention, a moment in which I was neither listening to the news nor thinking about any particular event or person, that I was overcome by grief. It was one of the first moments in which I realized that the greater struggle is still awaiting us: not only the struggle with the state of emergency itself and with the atrocities that had unfolded during and in the wake of it, but also with its long-term consequences, those that remained largely invisible.
Almost three years have passed since that moment, yet the event about which I write is not behind us. We are still living through it. The challenge of writing under such circumstances is particularly profound, because it cannot rely on the privileged vantage point of hindsight. My understandings do not derive their authority from the distance that history eventually affords. They are being written as a living journal of thought.
Among the most traumatic dimensions of the catastrophe of October 7 was the experience of prolonged abandonment. As the hours passed, what initially appeared to be a localized failure gradually revealed itself as a comprehensive collapse, a collapse of the very possibility of believing, trusting, or hoping that horror has limits, and that there are authorities entrusted with safeguarding those limits.
That abandonment did not end in the days that followed the catastrophe. In some nightmarish respects, it continued to expand, extending into ever wider spheres of life. It cast the terror of helplessness not only upon those directly affected by the attacks but upon everyone living under the protection of those who had abandoned them, and who, in many ways, continue to abandon them still.
Set against this experience of abandonment, the greatest source of consolation these difficult years have offered has been the extraordinary capacity for human solidarity displayed both in the midst of the catastrophe and in its aftermath. Ordinary citizens stepped forward in ways that far exceeded the limits of their time, their strength, and even their own sense of what they were capable of. In the vacuum created by the almost complete absence of leadership, they succeeded in creating a form of civic leadership that arose precisely where official one had failed.
Positive versus Negative Solidarity
In her book on the healing power of solidarity, Kogan (2023), an Israeli Psychoanalyst, contrasts two forms of solidarity. The first is “solidarity with those similar to me” – one which derives from identification with others, and the second is “solidarity as the transcendence of the self” – a radical form of solidarity with others’ interest even if that interest is not a shared one.
Following Adriana Cavarero (2016, p. 64) Kogan describes both types of solidarity in terms of an ethics of body gestures: while “solidarity with those similar to me” is characterized by an ethics of “reaching out”, holding out a hand, or standing “shoulder to shoulder”, and is therefore marked by a horizontal, equal positionality – “solidarity as the transcendence of the self” is marked by a vertical leaning toward the other in need.
“Solidarity with those similar to me” consists of an attitude of mutual commitment vis-à-vis the community which the individual regards as an extension of themselves, a community whose cultural background, values, interests, and world view they share. This form of solidarity is grounded in an experience of identification, empathy with an other who is perceived as similar to the self. As such, however, “solidarity with those similar to me” generates an experience of “us”, and therefore an implied distinction between “us” and “them”, due to which it will not easily extend toward an other whose world view is wholly different, and which one’s imagination will find it hard to envision. Unlike “solidarity with those similar to me” which is based on an actual connection between one individual and another, “solidarity as the transcendence of the self” is based on a radical departure from any actual experience of a common fate, similarity, or empathy. The one dimension shared by the individual who feels solidarity and the person with whom they feel solidarity is the fact that they are both humans. This gesture of solidarity is associated with an ethics of standing against injustice and unlike the “solidarity with those similar to me”, it emanates from the perception of a shared, general human essence over and beyond actual differences.
The last two difficult years in Israel have, in a certain sense, brought these two types of solidarity to light. Alongside the manifestations of “solidarity with those similar to me,” which were expressed in all types of civic action on behalf of the hostages and those evacuated and displaced from their homes following the October 7 attack, the public arena has also seen manifestations of “solidarity as the transcendence of the self,” including the humanitarian mobilization of Israeli citizens on behalf of Gazan citizens, as well as the mobilization of citizens of foreign countries on behalf of Israeli victims of the disaster.
Following these two types of positive solidarity, consisting of various forms of turning towards the other, whether real or symbolic – I would like to introduce what I call “negative solidarity” (Amir, 2024), which constitutes another broken link. We may think of this form of solidarity as embodied by the physical gesture of “back-to-back”. This is a type of leaning on the other which, on the one hand supplies stable support, in the shape of the other’s body weight, yet neither turns nor refers to that other. Anyone who has ever tried to lean on another person in this way knows that it is possible to get up only when both parties do it together. In that sense, this type of solidarity makes it impossible to rise individually. As soon as only one of the pair rises, the other falls. As a result, all they can do is either sit together or rise together.
Whereas positive solidarity is characterized by cooperation, negative solidarity is characterized by collaboration. While cooperation is vital and creative, collaboration aims to block any free movement. Collaboration of this kind, produced by negative solidarity, is reflected in various hidden pacts between one person and another, as well as between citizens and government, pacts which consecrate homogeneity and condemn plurality.
Implicit contracts of both types can also be thought of as contracts signed unconsciously between the person and him-or-herself. An internal contract based on positive solidarity is a contract based on the pursuit of knowledge of the inner truth, in the language of Bion (1962), or one that invites movement between different self-states, in the language of Bromberg (Bromberg, 1998), including contradictory self-states or those that touch the intolerable. On the other hand, an internal contract based on negative solidarity is a contract based on a false self-unity, or on a pseudo-wholeness that prevents any kind of reflection and introspection that could generate feelings of guilt or regret. When the contract that a person signs with him-or-herself is based on the negation of internal multiplicity in order to preserve an experience of apparent sanity or wholeness, the psychological price is one of transforming the mental three-dimensionality into two-dimensionality (the transition from three-dimensionality to two-dimensionality also characterizes the reactions of collectives, as will be demonstrated later, and not only of individuals). The therapeutic process can be thought of as one that aims to transform collaborative contracts that the patient unknowingly signs with themselves, which, by their very nature, require the flattening of mental stratification, into cooperative contracts that enable rich, multi-layered mental movement and self-realization.
Lebovits-Quenehen (2023) argues that the texture of the world of which haters dream has no bumps and holes, tears, or seams: it is a uniform, orderly whole without differences, one which holds out an illusion of total safety. However, this dream is not confined to individual haters only: regimes grounded in the hatred of others and otherness share it too.
Julia Kristeva (1991) points out that it is the face of the stranger that necessarily interrupts the banality and homogeneity that constitute human community. Following her, we might think of benighted regimes as designed precisely to produce this kind of “banal” community: a state of pseudo-unity and stability aimed to gather everything under what Kristeva calls “the nationality code” (ibid. p. 2). The pseudo-hospitality these regimes produce through the creation of homogeneous communities seeks to achieve an elusive blurring of differences in order to host – yet also to jail – the strange and the stranger in their shared space. Their rhetoric holds out identity (in the sense of being-identical-to) while confiscating this very identity (in the sense of singularity).
Ideologies, as Arendt claimed (1951, p. 689), require a “total explanation”: ideological conviction can only be preserved when doubt and uncertainty, or in fact any form of self-examination, are removed from consciousness. Bollas, in “The Fascist State of Mind” (1992), argues that as long as the internal regime is democratic, words and symbols are free to associate with other words and symbols. But when representation becomes obstructed, signifiers lose this freedom. The elimination of the symbolic and the pluralistic is the fascist regime’s first act of murder: this is because the symbolic, always unbinding any fixed meaning and undermining any act of [negative] solidarity, is the true subversive element of thought.
The collaborationist attack on solidarity unfolds with the help of three key parameters, which turn thought into a saturated and blocked domain: Declaration of a state of emergency, false use of rationalization, and persistent numbing. These three parameters appear in combination, with variable dominance, in external as well as internal zones characterized by an attack on free thinking and free linking.
Canadian writer and cultural researcher Naomi Klein (2008) points out that, throughout history, emergencies have provided an opportunity for the domination of economic and political agendas. She quotes Carl Schmitt (1986), who argued that the sovereign is the one who decides on the state of emergency, and claims that behind every declaration of a state of emergency (medical, political, economic) there are forces operating that may make enormous profits from what they mark as a situation of no choice. These profits are, of course, related to the powers the state of emergency grants the government to make decisions on behalf of its citizens. Orna Kazin (2022) writes that a state of emergency is the fortress of those who seek absolute control. This is a state that ceases to fulfill its functions, one that prefers obedience and uniformity over conversation and diversity. In a state of emergency, it is not difficult to get citizens to rally behind leaders’ decisions, Kazin writes. They easily buy the story: there is a hurricane, a virus, a war, enemies arising from within and without, the government must take immediate steps, and there is no time for hesitation or moral considerations.
Besides the ongoing use by the Israeli government of the state of emergency parameter, we are currently witnessing widespread use of false rationalization by members of the leadership. Among other things, the circular claim is repeatedly made that the prolonged demonstrations against government policy that preceded the current disaster were not the ones that warned of it, but the ones that caused it, by conveying a message of weakness to Israel’s enemies.
The French psychoanalyst Piera Aulagnier (2001), who has written extensively on the development of the “future psychotic,” highlights the psychotic potential inherent in the educational rationalization of violent acts. She is referring to the ways in which the mother of the “future psychotic” uses sophisticated rationalization to justify her violence against her child, thus hiding from him her (unconscious) death wish for him. This creates an unbridgeable gap between her overt and covert messages: on the surface, it appears to be an educational message and actions taken for the child’s benefit. Under the visible layer, however, there is the mother’s death wish for the child, a death wish that not only does not express itself in words but also imposes a prohibition on the child’s capacity to think about it. In this context, Aulagnier uses the concept of “Newspeak,” which originates in Orwell’s novel 1984 (1949) and refers to a discourse that rewrites reality through the censorship it exerts on language; a discourse from which any possibility of a true relationship between internal experience and external reality is eliminated.
If we apply Aulagnier’s concepts to the current Israeli context, it can be argued that the psychotic potential in the messages of the current leadership stems from the fact that, like the mother of the future psychotic described by Aulagnier, they present a false linking. The gap between the overt rationalization and the truth that operate beneath the surface – not only enables the realization of harmful interests but also impairs the ability of citizens to identify these interests and defend themselves against them.
What is the “death wish” that lies behind these false rationalizations? According to Aulagnier, the mother’s death wish for the baby is not related to a wish for it to die, but rather to the wish to be born through it, that is, to a wish for it to serve as an object through which the mother is reborn instead of being a subject to whom she gives birth. It is not unreasonable to think of the current leadership’s use of the state of emergency – and the false rationalization that accompanies this use – as a variation on the psychotic’s mother’s desire to be born through him instead of allowing him to be born through her.
Finally, and as a natural extension of the two previous parameters, the experience of ongoing helplessness causes the public to withdraw.
Negative solidarity is always based, as stated above, on a two-dimensional perception of the human and humanity, that is, it is only possible when three-dimensionality is flattened. The parameters I have mentioned do indeed support two-dimensional modes of perception: emergency conditions distract from reflection to action; false rationalization gets in the way of critical thinking; helplessness numbs the sense of guilt and responsibility, thus numbs citizens’ experience of themselves as autonomous agents.
“Guardianship from Above” and “Guardianship from Below”
There is a natural balance between what I wish to call “Guardianship from Above” and “Guardianship from Below”. By the term “Guardianship from Above,” I do not mean guardianship in the religious sense. On the contrary. I wish to secularize this expression and attribute it to all types of responsibility of the upper echelons towards those under their protection. The responsibility of these echelons begins with responsibility for the lives and physical integrity of those for whom they are responsible. But it does not end or amount to that. A critical dimension of it is creating conditions that allow for thought, encourage expression, and invite a rich human fabric, even one embodied in manifestations of resistance. The “Guardianship from above” is not measured by the ways in which it protects those who identify with its worldview; it is also, perhaps primarily, measured by the ways in which it protects those who speak out against it. By “Guardianship from Below,” on the other hand, I mean those to whom the decisions of “Guardianship from above” apply – and who, in turn, are also guarantors of each other. One can think of “Guardianship from above” as a parental model, in which responsibility and power are exercised from above downwards, and of “Guardianship from Below” as a brotherly model in which the relationship is horizontal and egalitarian.
One of the characteristics of collective trauma zones is the disruption of the balance between “Guardianship from Above” and “Guardianship from Below”. This disruption has two prototypes that usually exist in combination: the first prototype is the disruption of the balance in the direction in which the “Guardianship from Above” is disconnected from the “Guardianship from Below”, assuming a false “hypertrophic” configuration (a configuration in which there is an artificial enlargement of one organ at the expense of another organ), a configuration in which there is no living dialogue, no connection, between the higher echelons and those under their protection; while the second prototype is the disruption of the balance in the direction of the expansion and thickening of the “Guardianship from Below” as a substitute for the “Guardianship from Above”, which is perceived as absent.
What characterizes the current period in Israel is the two types of disruption just described: both the hypertrophic disruption, characterized by the inflation of what pretends to be “Guardianship from Above” to monstrous, detached, blind dimensions – and the counter-disruption, characterized by the condensation of “Guardianship from Below” as a substitute for the absent “Guardianship from Above”.
These disruptions are familiar to us not only at the collective level but also at the individual level. Even at the level of the individual within traumatic territory, the balance between the internal objects belonging to the category of “Guardianship from Above” and those belonging to the category of “Guardianship from Below” is disrupted. This disruption may be expressed, for example, in the haunting guilt that accompanies disaster survivors, who take upon themselves, through it, responsibility for the deaths of their loved ones. It may also be expressed in the abandonment of trust in internalized infrastructures, which suddenly appear false and deceptive, and in a retreat into a state of detachment and hopelessness, a state that Gerson (2009) describes in his article “When the Third is Dead,” marking the loss of the living third (be it a person, a policy, or an institution) on whom the individual previously relied and in relation to whom he developed an experience of existential continuity and meaning.
Dori Laub (2005) argues that one of the characteristics of a traumatic situation is that it leaves the survivor without an addressee to turn to, neither outside nor within. The correction to this state, Laub argues, can only be through the re-creation of a shelter of human presence (Felman and Laub, 2008) that provides an experience of containment and meaning to the unbearable.
The situation in which the “Guardianship from Above” is absent, or the trust in it has been lost, does indeed require rebuilding a shelter of human presence, both at the individual and the collective levels: a redeployment that includes mobilizing good internal objects and their embodiment or realization outside. Unlike the natural developmental movement associated, at least partially, with the internalization of the actual good objects – what is required in these situations is a “corrective” movement, a countermovement from the inside out: the array of good internal objects, to the extent that there is one, must function in these situations as a compensatory array, embodying itself both in the form of good people and in the form of good actions that redraw the breadth of the human sphere.
Even if this is not consciously and openly formulated, the unstated goal of the vast majority of therapeutic interventions at traumatic times is the restoration of the balance that has been violated between the two types of guardianships, that is, the reestablishment of the natural structure that allows a living, rich dialogue between all types of guardianship, both outside and within. But the reestablishment of this structure cannot but go through the reestablishment of the freedom to think.
One of the characteristics of a collective traumatic situation is the deliberate use, as said, of the state of emergency, of false rationalizations and continuous numbing in order to invite a negative solidarity based on non-thought. The reason why this invitation to negative solidarity succeeds in achieving its goals is the prevalent tendency in extreme situations to collapse into reality, that is, to move all the forces of the body and mind toward the envelope, to strengthen the walls. This movement of forces toward the envelope, or the peripheral walls, necessarily requires a reduction in the possibility of staying in the space between these walls, that is, a reduction in the desire and freedom to think. In the therapeutic sessions this is often expressed in a repetitive focus on actual actions and concrete events, at the expense of the desire or ability to look inward. When we are in a toxic environment, the mind functions a bit like a bomb shelter: there are thick walls, but there is no reception, in the sense that the richness of external and internal discourse is diminished. We hold tightly to the shelter’s doors, lean against the walls, and position ourselves far from any windows, internal or external. But this clinging is precisely what keeps this situation going on. Against this disruption, the great challenge this period poses to us is restoring the ability to think and to connect.
I now recall a patient who, for several sessions following October 7, did not stop talking, eloquently and mechanically, about what was happening in the political and military reality. The things he said were most impressive in their precision and sharpness, but he, as a narrator, as a singular voice, was absent from them. At a certain moment, I said to him: “For several sessions now, I have felt that you are bringing a recording of yourself, and in fact you are not coming here. To continue listening to you like this is to pretend that I do not know that you are not here, and that you are not talking to me but rather beyond me.” He fell silent and wept. Then he said: “Yes, I know this empty talk of mine. You are right. Thank you for noticing that I did not come.”
The importance of this moment was not related to the specific content he was dealing with but rather to the possibility of re-establishing a natural relationship between the “Guardianship from Above” and the “Guardianship from Below”, a relationship that in turn gave him, but also myself, the freedom and possibility to think.
In situations of ongoing disaster, the natural tendency is to retreat inward into a state of survival. In these situations, any introspection, and by extension, any rich observation of the outside, is often perceived as a luxury. In fact, the opposite is true. Insisting on thinking is a condition for the reestablishment of the relationship between the “Guardianship from Above” and the “Guardianship from Below”, that is, for the reestablishment of the proper relationship between the protective walls and the space that extends between them. In contrast, clinging to the survival walls means sterilizing the space of thought. In order to restore thinking, the coordinates of false solidarity and false linking must be reconverted into coordinates of truth; the causality that was transformed into false rationalization must be reclaimed; so does the time and space for thought that were canceled in the name of the state of emergency.
Human Multiplicity as a Platform and a Horizon
Erich Fromm (1941/1994), who examined how each culture mediates what is allowed to enter its members’ consciousness, proposed three socially conditioned filters: language, logic, and social taboo. He suggested that language connects to various social and cultural taboos by preserving the cultural “unspeakable” and preventing it from being expressed or thought. As a result, we may experience something that not only does not cross our lips but does not cross our minds, something that, in the absence of tools that allow us to formulate it, becomes a kind of “unthought”, repressed at best (because then it filters out of the unconscious through subversive means such as dreams, slips of the tongue, etc.) – and denied or removed from consciousness at worst (in which case it becomes a kind of disconnected enclave that is not even located in the unconscious).
To continue Fromm, the greatest resistance, in fact the only possible one, to what attacks thinking – is related to extracting language from its trap as a conditioned filter: its transformation from that which preserves the unspeakable to that which struggles for speech; from that which produces the known that is not thought – to that which connects the thought with the known; from a collaborative force that excludes any kind of multiplicity – to a cooperative force that perceives human multiplicity as both a platform and a horizon.
References
Amir D. (2017). ‘Screen confessions’: A fresh analysis of Nazi perpetrators’ ‘newspeak’. Psychoanalysis, Culture & Society Vol. 23, 1, 97–114.
Amir, D. & Hacohen N. (2020). “Screen Confessions: The Test Case of ‘Breaking the Silence’. International Journal of Applied Psychoanalytic Studies, 17 (4) 296-312.
Amir, D. & Hacohen N. (2021). “The Function of the Inner Witness in Interrupting Screening Mechanisms of Perpetrators’ Language”. International Journal of Applied Psychoanalytic Studies, vol 18(4). 363-371.
Amir D. (2024). From mind-deadness to mindedness, from collaboration to cooperation. International Journal of Applied Psychoanalytic Studies, 21(4), e1888.
Aulagnier P. (2001). The Violence of Interpretation. Trans: Alan Sheridan. London: Routledge.
Arendt H. (1951). The Origins of Totalitarianism. New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company.
Bion W. R. (1959). Attacks on linking. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 40, 308-315.
Bion W. R. (1970). Container and Contained Transformed. In Attention and Interpretation. London: Tavistock [Reprinted London: Karnac books, 1984], PP. 106-124.
Bollas C. (1992). “The fascist state of mind.” In: Being a Character: Psychoanalysis and Self Experience. New York: Routledge, pp. 193–217.
Bromberg P. M. (1998). Standing in the Spaces: Essays on Clinical Process, Trauma, and Dissociation. Hillsdale, NJ: The Analytic Press.
Cavarero A. (2016). Inclinations: A Critique of Rectitude (trans: Amanda Minervini & Adam Sitze). Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Coussin O. (2022). How to Resist – Israel as (No Longer) A Good Enough Nation. Tel-Aviv: Oliphant.
Felman S., Laub D. (1992). Testimony: crises of witnessing in literature, psychoanalysis, and history. New York and London: Routledge.
Fromm E. (1941/1994). Escape From Freedom. Henry Holt, New York: Owl Books Edition.
Gerson S. (2009). When the Third is Dead: Memory, Mourning, and Witnessing in the Aftermath of the Holocaust. The International Journal of Psycho-Analysis (90) 1341-1357.
Klein N. (2008). The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism. New-York: Picador.
Kogan C. (2023). The Healing Power of Solidarity: A Philosophical, Literary and Psychoanalytic Journey. Jerusalem: Carmel.
Kristev, J. (1991). Strangers to Ourselves (trans: Leon S. Roudiez). New-York: Columbia University Press.
Orwell G. (1949). 1984. London: Secker and Warburg.
Laub D. (2005). Traumatic Shutdown of Narrative and Symbolization. Contemporary Psychoanalysis, 41, 307-326.
Lebovits-Quenehen A. (2023). The Actuality of Hate (trans: Shula Haran). Tel-Aviv: Resling.
Schmitt C. (1986). Political Theology: Four Chapters on the Concept of Sovereignty (trans: George Schwab). Cambridge: MIT Press.
*Per citare questo articolo:
Amir D. (2026). On the Violation and the Restoration of Truth. Rivista KnotGarden 2026/2, Centro Veneto di Psicoanalisi, pp. 242-257.
Per una lettura più agile e per ulteriori riferimenti di pagina si consiglia di scaricare la Rivista in formato PDF.
Condividi questa pagina:
Centro Veneto di Psicoanalisi
Vicolo dei Conti 14
35122 Padova
Tel. 049 659711
P.I. 03323130280